Child's Ballads

Week 12: England - Assignments - Reading - Resources - Images


Two Daughters (Child 10)

Listening time: (4 minutes)

CHILD 10 versions A-Y. There is actually a version of this same story included in the English Fairy Tales option this week, under the title of Binnorie. Max Hunter actually recorded a number of variants of this song: one with a hat and diamond rings, one where the miller is hanged, and one with the refrain "Hi-yum-dum-dandy-o." There are also many variants recorded throughout Europe, as Lesley Nelson-Burns comments: "Versions of the ballad vary a great deal. In one version a harper comes to the body and makes a harp out of the breastbone (so "he can play it forever...") In a Norse version the authorities bring a pipe for the family to play to determine who killed her. When the sister plays the pipe, blood spews forth and the pipe plays of her guilt - so she is condemned and pulled apart by horses. One version from Sweden has a miller discover the girl and bringing her back to her family where she forgives her sister."

AUDIO RECORDING

VERSE 1
There was an old woman lived on th sea shore
Bow down
There was an old woman lived on th sea shore
Lord, have mercy on me
There was an old woman lived on th sea shore
She had some daughters, two or more
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

VERSE 2
Th youngest one, she had a beau
Bow down
Th youngest one, she had a beau
Lord, have mercy on me
The youngest one, she had a beau
An' th older one, she did'nt have none
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

VERSE 3
He gave to her a ten gold ring
Bow down
He gave to her a ten gold ring
Lord, have mercy on me
He gave to her a ten gold ring
An' he did'nt give the older one, a thing
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

[other versions say "gay gold ring" instead of "ten gold ring"]

VERSE 4
O sister, O sister, let's walk th sea shore
Bow down
O sister, O sister, let's walk th sea shore
Lord, have mercy on me
O sister, O sister, let's walk th sea shore
And see th ships as they sail o'er
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

VERSE 5
As they went walking along th stream
Bow down
As they went walking along th stream
Lord, have mercy on me
As they went walking along th stream
Th older one pushed th young one in
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

VERSE 6
O sister, O sister, just lend me your hand
Bow down
O sister, O sister, just lend me your hand
Lord, have mercy on me
O sister, O sister, just lend me your hand
I'll will to you my house and land
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

VERSE 7
She went on swiming, like a swan
Bow down
She went on swiming, like a swan
Lord, have mercy on me
She went on swiming, like a swan
And swum to th gates of th millers pond
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

VERSE 8
Th miller threw out his grab boat
Bow down
Th miller threw out his grab boat
Lord, have mercy on me
Th miller threw out his grab boat
And got poor Kate on shore once't more
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me

[other versions say "grab hook" instead of "grab boat"]

VERSE 9
She gave to him her ten gold ring
Bow down
She gave to him her ten gold ring
Lord, have mercy on me
She gave to him her ten gold ring
And he pushed her back in th brook again
Saying, I'll be true to my lover
My love'll be true to me


Questions. Make sure you can answer these questions about what you just read:

  • what present did the one sister receive from her lover?
  • what did her sister do to her?
  • what did she give to the miller when he rescued her? what did the miller do?

Source: From The Max Hunter Folksong Archive (weblink) and Lesley Nelson's Child Ballad website (weblink). See also Francis James Child, The English and Scottish Popular Ballads (1882-1898). Weblink.


Modern Languages / Anthropology 3043: Folklore & Mythology. Laura Gibbs, Ph.D. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License. You must give the original author credit. You may not use this work for commercial purposes. If you alter, transform, or build upon this work, you may distribute the resulting work only under a license identical to this one.
Page last updated: October 9, 2004 12:52 PM